OFAC Cannot Shut Down Open-Source Software
Haun Ventures
0xE02C
October 19th, 2022

By Katie Haun and James Rathmell

Since our post last month, there have been some further developments in reaction to the Tornado Cash sanctions, from Coinbase’s lawsuit to Treasury’s clarifying guidance and Coin Center’s complaint. We’re glad to see a strong response from the industry because we believe foundational principles are at play in this case. Namely, can governments ban open-source technology with sanctions, proscriptions, or embargoes that aren’t narrowly tailored? OFAC is right that many criminals have misused the Tornado Cash platform, but the stakes here go beyond Tornado Cash. The real question is whether the government can target the architecture of a blockchain itself, because what can be done to one kind of open-source protocol can be done to any open-source protocol.

I say this as someone who spent a decade prosecuting money launderers: the fight against illicit finance must be done in a way that’s legally sound. There’s a tried and true playbook for addressing money laundering if there exists sufficient evidence of intent to subvert the law — bringing prosecutions, enforcement actions, seizures, and other steps against bad actors.

Here, OFAC sanctioned Tornado Cash based upon IEEPA, a federal law that gives it the authority to block “any property in which any foreign country or a national thereof has any interest,” alleging that the protocol had been “commonly used by illicit actors to launder funds, especially those stolen during significant heists.” OFAC’s concerns in this respect are undoubtedly legitimate. But in issuing broad, indiscriminate sanctions against an open-source protocol writ large, the agency overstepped its legal authority to sanction the foreign hackers and their property in a way that leaves it exposed to both statutory and constitutional attack. It’s also produced a chilling effect for plenty of builders in the space who are rightly concerned whether OFAC’s view is now the law.

We don’t think it is.

Today, we’re publishing a legal memo that open sources the core arguments as to why, which we hope will be used in existing cases and ones still to come. When we thought about who to collaborate with on these arguments, Steve Engel was the first person who came to mind. Steve and I were co-clerks at the Supreme Court and he went on to lead the Office of Legal Counsel, the office that reviews the President’s executive orders for legality and also effectively serves as outside counsel for all executive branch agencies, including Treasury (read: Steve doesn’t hang out on crypto twitter so I called him up, explained the situation, and we brainstormed a bit).

The bottom line is that we think that OFAC went too far as a statutory matter because it appears to have blocked open-source, self-executing software that isn’t a person or the “property” of any foreign national or entity. IEEPA doesn’t grant such broad, roving authority to target open-source software architecture, and that is true no matter how noble OFAC’s intentions may have been. As the Supreme Court said in a recent case, our system of government “does not permit agencies to act unlawfully even in pursuit of desirable ends.”

What’s more, the agency has exposed itself to constitutional attack on a few fronts. It’s likely a court may not even reach the constitutional questions, however, because of the doctrine of constitutional avoidance which instructs courts to avoid ruling on constitutional issues when a case may be resolved on other statutory grounds. As the Supreme Court noted recently, the constitutional-avoidance canon provides “extra icing on a cake already frosted.” But suffice it to say these sanctions resulted in an asset freeze that deprived some innocent Americans of their property—without due process of law. And the sanctions may have violated the Fourth Amendment’s prohibition on unreasonable seizures to boot. Finally, while OFAC’s recent guidance shows that it recognizes the First Amendment problems inherent in altogether banning the publication of and interaction with code, its prohibition on the use of Tornado Cash code burdens the ability of Americans to use the privacy-enabling application to facilitate anonymous speech. That itself raises a substantial First Amendment issue.

Speaking of extra icing, sanctioning open-source code is also bad policy. These sanctions are reminiscent of when the U.S. government attempted to curtail public access to encryption tools in the 1990s by banning the export of encryption technology. Had the U.S. criminalized the use of cryptography without a license, we would have a much less secure — and much less developed — internet today.

We think that OFAC has overstepped, and it should fix that sooner rather than later. The first Tornado Cash lawsuits have already been filed against OFAC in Texas and Florida, and these may not be the last. OFAC can and should focus its sanctions efforts on the bad actors who abuse open-source software, not on the tools themselves.

The full memo can be found here.

This post is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell securities or to pursue any particular investment strategy. This post should not be relied upon in evaluating the merits of any investment or any particular investment strategy. You should consult your own advisers as to business, financial, tax, legal, and all other related matters concerning any investment. The views expressed in this post reflect the current opinions of the authors and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Haun Ventures Management LP or its affiliates. Certain information in this post may have been obtained from third-party sources, including portfolio companies of Haun Ventures. While taken from sources that the authors believe to be reliable, Haun Ventures has not independently verified the accuracy of such information. Content is as of the date posted and subject to change without notice. Haun Ventures makes no representations about the enduring accuracy of information or its appropriateness for any given situation. Please see https://www.haun.co/disclosures for additional important information.

Subscribe to Haun Ventures
Receive the latest updates directly to your inbox.
Nft graphic
Mint this entry as an NFT to add it to your collection.
Verification
This entry has been permanently stored onchain and signed by its creator.
Arweave Transaction
N-cjcc7xThTo9tY…XxVsAsYFyHbvuoU
Author Address
0x80795DfeeAbCEf0…28a071410346419
Nft Address
0x587d2d732cDd2c6…15b45fc5a206536
Content Digest
ITTj2t5XoTYLH-3…89-wddRYbCkekPM
More from Haun Ventures
View All

Skeleton

Skeleton

Skeleton

500 Collectors
LOADING TEXT
#1
LOADING TEXT
#2
LOADING TEXT
#3
LOADING TEXT
#4
LOADING TEXT
#5
LOADING TEXT
#6
LOADING TEXT
#7
LOADING TEXT
#8
LOADING TEXT
#9
LOADING TEXT
#10
LOADING TEXT
#11
LOADING TEXT
#12
LOADING TEXT
#13
LOADING TEXT
#14
LOADING TEXT
#15
LOADING TEXT
#16
LOADING TEXT
#17
LOADING TEXT
#18
LOADING TEXT
#19
LOADING TEXT
#20
LOADING TEXT
#21
LOADING TEXT
#22
LOADING TEXT
#23
LOADING TEXT
#24
LOADING TEXT
#25
LOADING TEXT
#26
LOADING TEXT
#27
LOADING TEXT
#28
LOADING TEXT
#29
LOADING TEXT
#30
LOADING TEXT
#31
LOADING TEXT
#32
LOADING TEXT
#33
LOADING TEXT
#34
LOADING TEXT
#35
LOADING TEXT
#36
LOADING TEXT
#37
LOADING TEXT
#38
LOADING TEXT
#39
LOADING TEXT
#40
LOADING TEXT
#41
LOADING TEXT
#42
LOADING TEXT
#43
LOADING TEXT
#44
LOADING TEXT
#45
LOADING TEXT
#46
LOADING TEXT
#47
LOADING TEXT
#48
LOADING TEXT
#49
LOADING TEXT
#50
LOADING TEXT
#51
LOADING TEXT
#52
LOADING TEXT
#53
LOADING TEXT
#54
LOADING TEXT
#55
LOADING TEXT
#56
LOADING TEXT
#57
LOADING TEXT
#58
LOADING TEXT
#59
LOADING TEXT
#60
LOADING TEXT
#61
LOADING TEXT
#62
LOADING TEXT
#63
LOADING TEXT
#64
LOADING TEXT
#65
LOADING TEXT
#66
LOADING TEXT
#67
LOADING TEXT
#68
LOADING TEXT
#69
LOADING TEXT
#70
LOADING TEXT
#71
LOADING TEXT
#72
LOADING TEXT
#73
LOADING TEXT
#74
LOADING TEXT
#75
LOADING TEXT
#76
LOADING TEXT
#77
LOADING TEXT
#78
LOADING TEXT
#79
LOADING TEXT
#80
LOADING TEXT
#81
LOADING TEXT
#82
LOADING TEXT
#83
LOADING TEXT
#84
LOADING TEXT
#85
LOADING TEXT
#86
LOADING TEXT
#87
LOADING TEXT
#88
LOADING TEXT
#89
LOADING TEXT
#90
LOADING TEXT
#91
LOADING TEXT
#92
LOADING TEXT
#93
LOADING TEXT
#94
LOADING TEXT
#95
LOADING TEXT
#96
LOADING TEXT
#97
LOADING TEXT
#98
LOADING TEXT
#99
LOADING TEXT
#100
LOADING TEXT
#101
LOADING TEXT
#102
LOADING TEXT
#103
LOADING TEXT
#104
LOADING TEXT
#105
LOADING TEXT
#106
LOADING TEXT
#107
LOADING TEXT
#108
LOADING TEXT
#109
LOADING TEXT
#110
LOADING TEXT
#111
LOADING TEXT
#112
LOADING TEXT
#113
LOADING TEXT
#114
LOADING TEXT
#115
LOADING TEXT
#116
LOADING TEXT
#117
LOADING TEXT
#118
LOADING TEXT
#119
LOADING TEXT
#120
LOADING TEXT
#121
LOADING TEXT
#122
LOADING TEXT
#123
LOADING TEXT
#124
LOADING TEXT
#125
LOADING TEXT
#126
LOADING TEXT
#127
LOADING TEXT
#128
LOADING TEXT
#129
LOADING TEXT
#130
LOADING TEXT
#131
LOADING TEXT
#132
LOADING TEXT
#133
LOADING TEXT
#134
LOADING TEXT
#135
LOADING TEXT
#136
LOADING TEXT
#137
LOADING TEXT
#138
LOADING TEXT
#139
LOADING TEXT
#140
LOADING TEXT
#141
LOADING TEXT
#142
LOADING TEXT
#143
LOADING TEXT
#144
LOADING TEXT
#145
LOADING TEXT
#146
LOADING TEXT
#147
LOADING TEXT
#148
LOADING TEXT
#149
LOADING TEXT
#150
LOADING TEXT
#151
LOADING TEXT
#152
LOADING TEXT
#153
LOADING TEXT
#154
LOADING TEXT
#155
LOADING TEXT
#156
LOADING TEXT
#157
LOADING TEXT
#158
LOADING TEXT
#159
LOADING TEXT
#160
LOADING TEXT
#161
LOADING TEXT
#162
LOADING TEXT
#163
LOADING TEXT
#164
LOADING TEXT
#165
LOADING TEXT
#166
LOADING TEXT
#167
LOADING TEXT
#168
LOADING TEXT
#169
LOADING TEXT
#170
LOADING TEXT
#171
LOADING TEXT
#172
LOADING TEXT
#173
LOADING TEXT
#174
LOADING TEXT
#175
LOADING TEXT
#176
LOADING TEXT
#177
LOADING TEXT
#178
LOADING TEXT
#179
LOADING TEXT
#180
LOADING TEXT
#181
LOADING TEXT
#182
LOADING TEXT
#183
LOADING TEXT
#184
LOADING TEXT
#185
LOADING TEXT
#186
LOADING TEXT
#187
LOADING TEXT
#188
LOADING TEXT
#189
LOADING TEXT
#190
LOADING TEXT
#191
LOADING TEXT
#192
LOADING TEXT
#193
LOADING TEXT
#194
LOADING TEXT
#195
LOADING TEXT
#196
LOADING TEXT
#197
LOADING TEXT
#198
LOADING TEXT
#199
LOADING TEXT
#200
LOADING TEXT
#201
LOADING TEXT
#202
LOADING TEXT
#203
LOADING TEXT
#204
LOADING TEXT
#205
LOADING TEXT
#206
LOADING TEXT
#207
LOADING TEXT
#208
LOADING TEXT
#209
LOADING TEXT
#210
LOADING TEXT
#211
LOADING TEXT
#212
LOADING TEXT
#213
LOADING TEXT
#214
LOADING TEXT
#215
LOADING TEXT
#216
LOADING TEXT
#217
LOADING TEXT
#218
LOADING TEXT
#219
LOADING TEXT
#220
LOADING TEXT
#221
LOADING TEXT
#222
LOADING TEXT
#223
LOADING TEXT
#224
LOADING TEXT
#225
LOADING TEXT
#226
LOADING TEXT
#227
LOADING TEXT
#228
LOADING TEXT
#229
LOADING TEXT
#230
LOADING TEXT
#231
LOADING TEXT
#232
LOADING TEXT
#233
LOADING TEXT
#234
LOADING TEXT
#235
LOADING TEXT
#236
LOADING TEXT
#237
LOADING TEXT
#238
LOADING TEXT
#239
LOADING TEXT
#240
LOADING TEXT
#241
LOADING TEXT
#242
LOADING TEXT
#243
LOADING TEXT
#244
LOADING TEXT
#245
LOADING TEXT
#246
LOADING TEXT
#247
LOADING TEXT
#248
LOADING TEXT
#249
LOADING TEXT
#250
LOADING TEXT
#251
LOADING TEXT
#252
LOADING TEXT
#253
LOADING TEXT
#254
LOADING TEXT
#255
LOADING TEXT
#256
LOADING TEXT
#257
LOADING TEXT
#258
LOADING TEXT
#259
LOADING TEXT
#260
LOADING TEXT
#261
LOADING TEXT
#262
LOADING TEXT
#263
LOADING TEXT
#264
LOADING TEXT
#265
LOADING TEXT
#266
LOADING TEXT
#267
LOADING TEXT
#268
LOADING TEXT
#269
LOADING TEXT
#270
LOADING TEXT
#271
LOADING TEXT
#272
LOADING TEXT
#273
LOADING TEXT
#274
LOADING TEXT
#275
LOADING TEXT
#276
LOADING TEXT
#277
LOADING TEXT
#278
LOADING TEXT
#279
LOADING TEXT
#280
LOADING TEXT
#281
LOADING TEXT
#282
LOADING TEXT
#283
LOADING TEXT
#284
LOADING TEXT
#285
LOADING TEXT
#286
LOADING TEXT
#287
LOADING TEXT
#288
LOADING TEXT
#289
LOADING TEXT
#290
LOADING TEXT
#291
LOADING TEXT
#292
LOADING TEXT
#293
LOADING TEXT
#294
LOADING TEXT
#295
LOADING TEXT
#296
LOADING TEXT
#297
LOADING TEXT
#298
LOADING TEXT
#299
LOADING TEXT
#300
LOADING TEXT
#301
LOADING TEXT
#302
LOADING TEXT
#303
LOADING TEXT
#304
LOADING TEXT
#305
LOADING TEXT
#306
LOADING TEXT
#307
LOADING TEXT
#308
LOADING TEXT
#309
LOADING TEXT
#310
LOADING TEXT
#311
LOADING TEXT
#312
LOADING TEXT
#313
LOADING TEXT
#314
LOADING TEXT
#315
LOADING TEXT
#316
LOADING TEXT
#317
LOADING TEXT
#318
LOADING TEXT
#319
LOADING TEXT
#320
LOADING TEXT
#321
LOADING TEXT
#322
LOADING TEXT
#323
LOADING TEXT
#324
LOADING TEXT
#325
LOADING TEXT
#326
LOADING TEXT
#327
LOADING TEXT
#328
LOADING TEXT
#329
LOADING TEXT
#330
LOADING TEXT
#331
LOADING TEXT
#332
LOADING TEXT
#333
LOADING TEXT
#334
LOADING TEXT
#335
LOADING TEXT
#336
LOADING TEXT
#337
LOADING TEXT
#338
LOADING TEXT
#339
LOADING TEXT
#340
LOADING TEXT
#341
LOADING TEXT
#342
LOADING TEXT
#343
LOADING TEXT
#344
LOADING TEXT
#345
LOADING TEXT
#346
LOADING TEXT
#347
LOADING TEXT
#348
LOADING TEXT
#349
LOADING TEXT
#350
LOADING TEXT
#351
LOADING TEXT
#352
LOADING TEXT
#353
LOADING TEXT
#354
LOADING TEXT
#355
LOADING TEXT
#356
LOADING TEXT
#357
LOADING TEXT
#358
LOADING TEXT
#359
LOADING TEXT
#360
LOADING TEXT
#361
LOADING TEXT
#362
LOADING TEXT
#363
LOADING TEXT
#364
LOADING TEXT
#365
LOADING TEXT
#366
LOADING TEXT
#367
LOADING TEXT
#368
LOADING TEXT
#369
LOADING TEXT
#370
LOADING TEXT
#371
LOADING TEXT
#372
LOADING TEXT
#373
LOADING TEXT
#374
LOADING TEXT
#375
LOADING TEXT
#376
LOADING TEXT
#377
LOADING TEXT
#378
LOADING TEXT
#379
LOADING TEXT
#380
LOADING TEXT
#381
LOADING TEXT
#382
LOADING TEXT
#383
LOADING TEXT
#384
LOADING TEXT
#385
LOADING TEXT
#386
LOADING TEXT
#387
LOADING TEXT
#388
LOADING TEXT
#389
LOADING TEXT
#390
LOADING TEXT
#391
LOADING TEXT
#392
LOADING TEXT
#393
LOADING TEXT
#394
LOADING TEXT
#395
LOADING TEXT
#396
LOADING TEXT
#397
LOADING TEXT
#398
LOADING TEXT
#399
LOADING TEXT
#400
LOADING TEXT
#401
LOADING TEXT
#402
LOADING TEXT
#403
LOADING TEXT
#404
LOADING TEXT
#405
LOADING TEXT
#406
LOADING TEXT
#407
LOADING TEXT
#408
LOADING TEXT
#409
LOADING TEXT
#410
LOADING TEXT
#411
LOADING TEXT
#412
LOADING TEXT
#413
LOADING TEXT
#414
LOADING TEXT
#415
LOADING TEXT
#416
LOADING TEXT
#417
LOADING TEXT
#418
LOADING TEXT
#419
LOADING TEXT
#420
LOADING TEXT
#421
LOADING TEXT
#422
LOADING TEXT
#423
LOADING TEXT
#424
LOADING TEXT
#425
LOADING TEXT
#426
LOADING TEXT
#427
LOADING TEXT
#428
LOADING TEXT
#429
LOADING TEXT
#430
LOADING TEXT
#431
LOADING TEXT
#432
LOADING TEXT
#433
LOADING TEXT
#434
LOADING TEXT
#435
LOADING TEXT
#436
LOADING TEXT
#437
LOADING TEXT
#438
LOADING TEXT
#439
LOADING TEXT
#440
LOADING TEXT
#441
LOADING TEXT
#442
LOADING TEXT
#443
LOADING TEXT
#444
LOADING TEXT
#445
LOADING TEXT
#446
LOADING TEXT
#447
LOADING TEXT
#448
LOADING TEXT
#449
LOADING TEXT
#450
LOADING TEXT
#451
LOADING TEXT
#452
LOADING TEXT
#453
LOADING TEXT
#454
LOADING TEXT
#455
LOADING TEXT
#456
LOADING TEXT
#457
LOADING TEXT
#458
LOADING TEXT
#459
LOADING TEXT
#460
LOADING TEXT
#461
LOADING TEXT
#462
LOADING TEXT
#463
LOADING TEXT
#464
LOADING TEXT
#465
LOADING TEXT
#466
LOADING TEXT
#467
LOADING TEXT
#468
LOADING TEXT
#469
LOADING TEXT
#470
LOADING TEXT
#471
LOADING TEXT
#472
LOADING TEXT
#473
LOADING TEXT
#474
LOADING TEXT
#475
LOADING TEXT
#476
LOADING TEXT
#477
LOADING TEXT
#478
LOADING TEXT
#479
LOADING TEXT
#480
LOADING TEXT
#481
LOADING TEXT
#482
LOADING TEXT
#483
LOADING TEXT
#484
LOADING TEXT
#485
LOADING TEXT
#486
LOADING TEXT
#487
LOADING TEXT
#488
LOADING TEXT
#489
LOADING TEXT
#490
LOADING TEXT
#491
LOADING TEXT
#492
LOADING TEXT
#493
LOADING TEXT
#494
LOADING TEXT
#495
LOADING TEXT
#496
LOADING TEXT
#497
LOADING TEXT
#498
LOADING TEXT
#499
LOADING TEXT
#500