Navigating the Murky Waters ofย DAOs


  • Power dynamics, trust, and organizational structure are interleaved factors in the success of decentralized organizations.

  • Off-chain operations and decision-making processes can lead to power imbalances and a lack of trust within DAO communities.

  • Better tokenizing operational structures by leveraging emerging protocols and tools can help create transparent and trustless power and value flows.

Wading into the Water

The rapidly evolving world of decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) presents unique challenges in addressing power dynamics, trust, and organizational structure. Navigating these murky waters is essential for the success of these innovative entities. ๐ŸŒŠ๐Ÿ—บ๏ธ

In this article, we'll explore the pitfalls of current approaches within DAOs, discuss the importance of trust in creating effective communities, and dive into innovative strategies and emerging protocols for more transparent and trustless power distribution. ๐Ÿšง๐Ÿ”ง

DAOs, with their transparent governance and token-based power distribution, have opened up a new world of possibilities for organizations. They offer an innovative approach to decision-making, and the idea of decentralization is what gives them their unique charm. However, DAOs are not without their challenges, especially when it comes to power and trust.

At first glance, DAOs seem to have it all figured out. Their on-chain governance contracts and token distribution systems offer a level of transparency that's unheard of in traditional organizations. This foundation of trust, where everyone can see how power is distributed and exercised, is one of the main reasons why DAOs are gaining traction. ๐Ÿš€

But, as the saying goes, "All that glitters is not gold." ๐Ÿ’ซ While the foundation of a DAO may be transparent and easy to understand, the reality is that once the power starts to flow from this foundation, it often generates off-chain, opaque, and dynamic structures that are far more difficult to trust.

The Dark Side of Off-Chain Operations

The learning curve is painful
The learning curve is painful

Think of a DAO structure like a river: the source of the river (the on-chain governance contracts and related tokens) is crystal clear, but as the water flows downstream, it can become muddied with off-chain decisions, informal arrangements, and human motivations. This murky water can make it challenging for community members to trust that power is being distributed fairly and transparently. ๐ŸŒŠ๐Ÿ˜•

These off-chain structures are often created out of necessity. DAO operations need to be agile and responsive to the ever-changing needs of their communities. While on-chain governance is excellent for certain decisions, in its current form, it can be slow and cumbersome for others. As a result, DAOs frequently resort to off-chain structures and decisions to navigate day-to-day challenges combined with simplistic on-chain structures like โ€˜Teams are just multiSigsโ€™โ€™. This can create a web of power structures and value flows that are hard to follow and understand, let alone trust.

As these mostly off-chain structures grow, they can become breeding grounds for power struggles, misaligned incentives, and even malicious actors. The lack of transparency in these structures can make it difficult to pinpoint the source of issues and resolve them effectively. This is where a playful, meme-loving DAO community can find itself in the clutches of Moloch, the god of coordination failure. ๐Ÿ‘ฟ๐Ÿ˜Ÿ

So, how do we strike the right balance between the agility and transparency that a DAO needs? One solution lies in creating a structure that is clear, accessible, and easy to understand. This involves mapping the power distribution within the DAO and making this information available to the community. By doing so, members can engage in meaningful discussions about power dynamics, rewards, and incentives, and make informed decisions about the organization's future. ๐Ÿ—บ๏ธ๐Ÿ’ก

Mapping Power and Value Distributions

Understanding the power distribution within a DAO is crucial for fostering trust and promoting a healthy organization. Letโ€™s discuss the process of mapping power distribution in DAOs and explore how this map can help identify power imbalances and improve trust within the community.

Creating a map of power distribution in a DAO involves documenting the relationships between different stakeholders, roles, and decision-making processes. This map should provide a clear and comprehensive picture of how the structure creates or influences the way power and value flow through the organization, from the on-chain governance contracts and DAO treasury, all the way down to the team and role accountability units. ๐ŸŒ๐Ÿ“

To create this map, start by identifying the members of the DAO. These might include token holders, governance participants, core team members, and external contributors. Next, outline the roles and responsibilities of each unit, the decision-making processes that they are involved in, the funds they control, and the rewards they receive. This will help illuminate how power and value are flowing across the organization. ๐Ÿ”ฆ

But remember, the structure of a DAO is dynamic and ever-evolving. As the organization grows and changes, so too should the map of power distribution. Regularly updating and sharing this map with the community will ensure that everyone remains informed and engaged in the decision-making process. This ongoing dialogue is vital for maintaining trust and promoting a healthy DAO environment. ๐Ÿ”„๐ŸŒฟ

Tokenizing Structure = Clarity AND Efficiency

Tokenizing the structure of a DAO can help to establish a more transparent system of power distribution and create more trustless power and value flows. By denoting the teams and roles contributors hold on-chain, DAOs can create a clear map of their organizational structure that is accessible to all community members. This can foster trust and collaboration and generate operational efficiencies through on-chain automation, all while reducing the risks associated with opaque, off-chain structures. ๐Ÿ—๏ธ๐Ÿ”—

Emerging non-transferable NFT (ntNFT) protocols, such as HatsProtocol, Otterspace, and many others, can be used to model structures on-chain. Tools like Sobol can help visualize these structures, making it easier for community members to understand how power and rewards are distributed within the DAO. With these technologies, DAOs can create a transparent system that drives power and value distributions based on a tokenized organizational structure. ๐Ÿ› ๏ธ๐ŸŒ

For example, imagine a DAO with various teams, each with their own Gnosis Safe. Role-based NFTs could be assigned to contributors, automatically adding or removing them as signers of the respective Safes, with the right on-chain modules. Additional contracts could be used to enable team role holders to permissionlessly withdraw a monthly "salary" from the Safe, provided they hold a valid role-denoting NFT. In this scenario, reputation, decision-making, and access to value flows are all automated and transparent, fostering trust within the community.

This is just a starting point, many patterns are emerging to place a DAOs operational structure on-chain, creating a clear system for reputation-related power, decision-making power, and access to value flows. ๐Ÿš€๐Ÿ’ฐ

Tokenize structure and youโ€™ve tokenized power.

Beyond Structure and Tokens

Remember, having an on-chain and tokenized structure is just the beginning. It's equally important to ensure that the structure is effective and meets the goals and interests of the community. This means designing structures that promote effective decision-making, efficient allocation of resources, and a balance between the autonomy of individuals and the collective goals of the DAO. ๐Ÿ’ญ๐Ÿ“ฃ

Tokenizing structure and power can offer numerous benefits in terms of transparency, security, and automation, but it's essential not to lose sight of the human aspect. Embrace the playfulness and creativity of your community becauseโ€ฆย 

The Future of Work = The Future of Playย 

Remember that even the most complex and sophisticated on-chain structure will only be as strong as the relationships and trust that bind the community together.

As DAOs continue to evolve, it's crucial that we address the challenges surrounding power, trust, and structure. By tokenizing organizational structures, fostering open dialogue, and creating an environment that encourages trust and collaboration we can make the kind of DAOs that we dreamed of when we first joined this movement together. ๐Ÿš€๐ŸŒŸ

Letโ€™s build it together!

If you're interested in tokenizing your DAOโ€™s power structure and discovering the best approach to using tools like Sobol and protocols like HatsProtocol, reach out to our team in our Discord Community Server for support in navigating this exciting journey!

Subscribe to "You Are Here" โ€“ The Sobol Blog
Receive the latest updates directly to yourย inbox.
This entry has been permanently stored onchain and signed by its creator.