The Dark Age of the US Entrepreneurial Landscape

The Setup

Europe was mired in a period of cultural and intellectual decline known as the "Dark Ages" in the early Middle Ages, owing in part to the continent's non-secular nature and religious dogma's suppression of scientific and technological advancement. As scholars in locations like Baghdad embraced and advanced the sciences, the Middle East blossomed into a learning powerhouse.

The Abbasid Caliphate was a driving factor behind the Middle East's intellectual and cultural boom. (750-1258 CE). The establishment of Baghdad as the caliphate's capital in 762 CE resulted in the establishment of the House of Wisdom, a famous center for learning and study. Scholars from all over the world, including Persians, Greeks, Indians, and Chinese, met at the House of Wisdom to translate, study, and add to the world's knowledge.

Abbasid Dynasty
Abbasid Dynasty

The Islamic Golden Age fostered numerous innovations and scientific advances during this period. Al-Khwarizmi, a Persian polymath, established the foundations of modern algebra, while Al-Razi, a prominent Persian physician, made important advances to medicine, chemistry, and philosophy. The astronomical data inherited from the Greeks and Indians was refined by renowned astronomer and mathematician Al-Battani, and Ibn Sina's Canon of Medicine became a standard medical book in both the Islamic world and Europe for centuries.

The Middle East's approach to education and knowledge differed significantly from that of Europe. While Europe's non-secular society stifled scientific and technological advancement, the Middle East adopted a more inclusive and open-minded approach to education. Scholars from different religious and cultural backgrounds were urged to share and collaborate, fostering an environment of intellectual curiosity and innovation.

The Joke

Fast forward to 2023, and the United States, once known for its innovation, is succumbing to a similar destiny. This time, however, it is not religious orthodoxy but an ever-expanding web of regulations (or lack thereof) that is impeding development. Today, we look at how the regulatory environment in the United States is driving innovation away and transforming countries like the UAE into new centers of progress.

"Regulations smother innovation."
"Regulations smother innovation."

The United States has been a hotbed of innovation since its inception, leading the world in cutting-edge discoveries, technological breakthroughs, and creative entrepreneurship. This tradition has been the driving force behind the country's economic growth and worldwide dominance. However, the regulatory burden on American businesses and innovators has increased exponentially over the last few decades.

The latest Wells notice served on Coinbase exemplifies the dangers of a rigid regulatory landscape. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) issued a stern warning, threatening legal action against the popular cryptocurrency exchange if it went ahead with plans to introduce a lending product. This move exemplifies the difficulties that innovators face in the United States, where regulators are frequently more concerned with preserving the status quo than with fostering the development of new industries.

Brian Armstrong, CEO of Coinbase
Brian Armstrong, CEO of Coinbase

Another example is India's recent efforts to tax cryptocurrencies and fintech startups more heavily. This restrictive strategy has the potential to stifle growth in these sectors, causing entrepreneurs and investors to seek out more welcoming jurisdictions. These regulatory barriers chill innovation by discouraging entrepreneurs from pursuing ground-breaking ideas and stifling the development of emerging sectors. The high cost of compliance, the complexity of navigating the regulatory environment, and the uncertainty surrounding future regulations all work together to stifle innovation and progress.

This situation has provided an opportunity for hubs such as Dubai and the UAE, which have adopted a more progressive regulatory strategy. By cultivating a business-friendly atmosphere that encourages experimentation and risk-taking, they have established themselves as global innovation hubs. This is reflected in the rapid expansion of their technology, finance, and renewable energy industries.

While the United States is mired in red tape, the UAE is actively investing in cutting-edge technologies such as artificial intelligence and blockchain, as well as encouraging the development of the space industry. In addition, the country has streamlined its business registration procedures and established special economic zones to attract global talent and investment.

SJM Group partnering with Draper Goren Holm portco, Casper Labs
SJM Group partnering with Draper Goren Holm portco, Casper Labs

The UAE have adopted a more progressive regulatory approach, establishing themselves as global innovation centers. Dubai's tax-free regulations and business-friendly environment have attracted global talent and money. The UAE has simplified its business registration procedures, established special economic zones, and made significant investments in emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, blockchain, and the space industry.

Other jurisdictions, such as Singapore and Estonia, have implemented forward-thinking regulatory frameworks that actively encourage innovation. These countries understand the importance of an agile, adaptable regulatory environment in attracting entrepreneurs and capital and positioning themselves at the forefront of the Fourth Industrial Revolution.

The innovative spirit that propelled the United States to worldwide dominance is on the verge of fading. Otherwise, we risk losing our once-proud tradition of innovation to countries better positioned to capitalize on the opportunities of the digital era.

The Punchline

To reverse this trend and keep the United States from entering the "Dark Ages" of innovation, lawmakers must act quickly to reduce the regulatory burden on businesses and innovators. This includes streamlining and modernizing regulations, as well as encouraging a more collaborative relationship between regulators and the businesses they regulate.

Here, I’m outlining three propositions that could foster a more progressive economic landscape and empower the next generation of entrepreneurs and innovators.

1. Enable cryptocurrency and custodian-verified stablecoins to be accepted as cash-equivalents.

Cryptocurrencies and stablecoins have the potential to revolutionize the global financial system, offering greater transparency, security, and efficiency. By recognizing custodian-verified stablecoins as cash equivalents, governments can encourage their integration into the mainstream economy and promote financial inclusivity. This move would not only simplify cross-border transactions but also reduce reliance on traditional banking systems. GAAP is not a standard we can rely on any longer…

Recognizing these digital assets as cash equivalents would pave the way for their use in a variety of applications, such as remittances, international trade, and investment. It would also incentivize the development of innovative financial products and services that leverage the unique benefits of cryptocurrencies and stablecoins. To ensure a smooth transition, regulators must collaborate with industry stakeholders to establish clear guidelines and create a legal framework that balances consumer protection with the encouragement of innovation.

2. Enable economic incentives to align for student and worker immigration in big tech to build their own companies given sufficient financing.

Immigrants have historically played a crucial role in driving innovation and economic growth. By creating economic incentives that encourage talented students and workers in big tech to start their own companies, governments can foster a more vibrant entrepreneurial ecosystem. This can be achieved through policies such as tax breaks, relaxed immigration requirements, and access to startup capital for qualifying entrepreneurs.

These incentives would not only attract top talent from around the world but also encourage the development of new technologies and industries. By creating a business-friendly environment that supports entrepreneurial risk-taking, policymakers can ensure that their countries remain competitive in the global race for innovation. It is crucial, however, to strike a balance between incentivizing entrepreneurship and protecting local industries and job markets. We need another Brain Drain. Fast.

3. Enable a continuation of ownership clause for investments made into college students' companies with educational safeguards.

Investing in the next generation of entrepreneurs is vital to ensuring the future of innovation. To fully capitalize on the potential of student founders, it is essential to not only enable a continuation of ownership clauses for investments made into their companies but also to ensure that they can gain experience by building great companies without having to sacrifice their education.

To achieve this, investors and student founders can integrate a "continuation of ownership with educational safeguards" clause into term sheets. This clause would allow investors to maintain their stake in the founder's future ventures, even if the initial company fails, while also acknowledging the importance of the founder's academic pursuits. The clause would include provisions that protect the student's educational interests, such as:

  • Flexible work arrangements: Student founders would be allowed to balance their academic commitments with their entrepreneurial responsibilities, ensuring that their education remains a priority.

  • Academic milestones: The clause could stipulate that certain milestones, such as maintaining a minimum GPA or completing a specific degree program, must be met to maintain the investor's continued support and ownership stake.

  • Leave of absence provision: If a student founder's company requires their full attention for a limited time, they could be granted a leave of absence from their academic institution, with the understanding that they will return to complete their education.

  • Mentorship and support: Investors would commit to providing mentorship and guidance to the student founders, helping them navigate the challenges of balancing their academic and entrepreneurial pursuits.

  • Reintegration support: In the event that a student founder's venture fails or they decide to exit the company, the clause would outline support mechanisms to help them reintegrate into their academic environment and complete their education.

By integrating a "continuation of ownership with educational safeguards" clause into term sheets, investors can encourage and support student entrepreneurs while recognizing the importance of their academic pursuits. This approach fosters a symbiotic relationship between investors and founders, wherein both parties stand to benefit from the student's entrepreneurial successes without compromising their educational foundation.

The creative spirit is the lifeblood of progress, and the United States must acknowledge the need for a more agile, adaptive regulatory framework that supports, rather than suffocates, the creative spirit. Otherwise, the country risks losing its once-proud heritage of innovation as other countries forge ahead into the future.

Subscribe to Sid Sridhar
Receive the latest updates directly to your inbox.
Mint this entry as an NFT to add it to your collection.
This entry has been permanently stored onchain and signed by its creator.